Caught in Between
Jun 18th, 2009 by pedestrian
This moment, I want to know NOTHING more than the actual results of this election. If not anything, with an 81% turnout rate, it would give me a good mirror into what Iran is like today.
That, we will never know.
But since I’ve been only been writing from my own perspective the last few days, I thought I should also put up some links about other views.
99 has many things to say about the current election. Especially keeping in mind Seymour Hersh who has been reporting about the JSOC hit squads sent in, and the funding of terrorist groups’ actions against Iran. Watch this video.
South/South gives a very interesting conversation with her grandmother.
Joshua Kucera, speaks out for many of us when he doubts the hype behind Twitter. (99 said it best! They’re Twittering our fucking brains out 24/7)
Djavad Salehi-Isfahani asks: Is the election pitting the poor vs. the middle class?
The Leverett’s declare (a tad arrogantly IMO): Ahamdinejad Won. Get over it.
I think that for many of us Iranians, it is extremely difficult not to get sucked into the vortex of either argument. We are either accused of being pro-West, pro-AIPAC or out of touch with the majority of Iranians. Here is a good rebuttal by Mansoor Moaddel to the latter argument in answer to Ballen and Doherty’s poll which they claim showed the accuracy of the election results.
One other thing I will say about the argument that claims: this election was not stolen, it just shows a deepening rift between the privileged minority who are unwilling to accept the results and the impoverished majority who voted overwhelmingly for Ahmainejad.
First of all, many of those arguments are coming from Western outlets to begin with – a source which isnt necessarily famous for understanding Iran.
Yes, Ahmadinejad did distribute goods among the poor. But there are a very limited number of poor people for whom $50 and a sack of potatoes was enough for them not to notice the disasterous toll the economy has taken.
One such example of this, which I can personally account, is the story of teachers. They were given a $50 bonus promised them since the new year two weeks before the election. Now teachers are some of Iran’s most impoverished workers. Not dirt poor enough to be labeled for charities, but extremely poor nonetheless.
I know for a fact that in my hometown, not only did this not warm them to Ahmadinejad, but angered them.
So unless I get the real, uncontested result of this election, that argument too just doesn’t add up.
But here are some of the things I certainly DON’T LIKE about the recent unfolding of events:
- RUMORS
The baseless gossip twirling around on Twitter, facebook and the main stream media.
Of course, if the state-sponsored radio and television in Iran had an OUNCE of integrity, none of these outlets would have been at all relevant to begin with.
Last night, both Reza Aslan (on CNN) and NIAC (on their own blog) declared via their own VERY questionable “sources” that “Some of my sources in Iran have told me that Ayatollah Rafsanjani, who is the head of the Assembly of Experts — the eighty-six member clerical body that decides who will be the next Supreme Leader, and is, by the way, the only group that is empowered to remove the Supreme Leader from power — that they have issued an emergency meeting in Qom. ”
My cousins in Iran have told me the same thing, so I’m not sure what sort of sources Aslan is quoting here.
These extremely baseless rumors have been going around the internet for days now, but to have a self-proclaimed “scholar” on CNN regurgitate this bullshit is the last straw. Since he uttered those statements, that bit of rumor has not left the Huffintong Post headlines or my facebook newsfeed.
In my facebook, there are also numerous obscure and vague photos of blood and gore. I am not talking about the CONFIRMED atrocities! But just to give you an example, one photo album that was being spread around, I was able to identify as one I’d seen six years ago after the earthquake in Bam.
- English Banners, References to Color-Coded Revolutions
Why are people in Iran holding so many English banners? I know why! They do that all the time, even in annual pro-government demonstrations to mark the anniversary of the revolution. The same reason all stores, from Tehran to my hometown of Dezful, have English banners instead of Persian ones. But we’ve never noticed it. Now, it is just too reminiscent of other color-coded revolutions.
- We DON’T NEED the Love
Why are Westerners suddenly so worried for Iran?
Glenn Greenwald said it best.
Twitter and Youtube have eased their operations for us. The headline at the HuffingtonPost has been the Iran election for the past week. The dope from NBC, Brian Williams, who only six months ago, spoke of us with despicable mocking words, now shows us the love every single night.
And this is coming from all sides. Respected Middle-East correspondent Robert Fisk has officially become a deranged maniac. The mind numbing “letter” he writes at lengths about, is the same one that has been going around as a JOKE on facebook for the past few days.
Milne writes a very poorly-argued article for the Guardian. Just because he targets the” educated elite”, doesn’t mean he understands Iranian society (or the candidates) any better.
The Cover of the Economist doesn’t help much.
WE DON’T WANT THE LOVE! KEEP IT TO YOURSELVES! FOR EIGHT YEARS WE WERE BOMBED AND GASSED AND MASSACRED AND NOBODY EVER SAID A WORD! I DON’T REMEMBER THE ECONOMIST DEDICATING A COVER TO OUR HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF DEAD BACK THEN! SHUT THE FUCK UP YOU HEINOUS, DESPICABLE SCOUNDRELS!


Complex Iran indeed!
Also just an afterthought. Perhaps today people are more involved because of the spike in communication technology. Who knows? After all, as you wrote elsewhere, we are all of the human family, are we not?
Take care!
Hi Gene!
Certainly the spike in communication technology has a lot to do with it! The fact that people like you read this stuff and talk about recent events is the positive side!
On the negative, there are certain media outlets that just don’t sound very sincere.
Thanks! You too!
I understand.
A Chinese dissident once said that his government’s greatest fear is the ‘chaos’ (his word) of diversity if there were more freedom in the country. Indeed ‘freedom’ also means having to manage ‘chaos’, not just for government but for us as well. Just a thought.
I suspect that the surge of sympathy towards the protesters has a lot to do with a feeling of pride and, yes, envy that the sight of a people fighting to achieve freedom inevitably brings up.
Unfortunately there are also the ghouls. In such circumstances, one must be careful not to throw out the baby with the bath water.
The ghouls are who I’m afraid of. Like you said, the only thing I can do is be careful …
All I can do is pray that this relative “chaos of diversity” on the streets of Tehran does not amount to anything fatal … Both on its own and by its misuse by people wanting to take advantage of the situation.
“…HEINOUS, DESPICABLE SCOUNDRELS!”
Now yer cookin’. Hear, hear! Sing it, girl.
:’(
I just don’t understand how some human beings can rejoice and relish the misery of others the way they do.
I love that picture
A great blog post.
I think the “chaos of diversity” has already had fatalities. But whether we put that down to diversity or brutality – what friends in Iran are saying is that they have felt a new energy, a new sense of urgency over the past 3 weeks. I hope this genie cannot be forced, coaxed or pummelled back into it’s lamp.
And I agree that there have been too many “Tanks rolling down Vali Asr!!!!” Twitter messages.
Hoping for a peaceful and just resolution to this unrest.
Homeyra Jan, isn’t it awesome?
John, with the speech Ayatollah Khamenei made today, everything has taken on a new turn.
The same western violent hypocrisy ….
HYPOCRISY is the word.