Growing Up – IRI style
Feb 24th, 2011 by pedestrian
It was the best of times, it was the worst of times … it was growing up in the Islamic Republic of Iran, in the late 90s and early 2000.
Not a day goes by without me thinking: “Ped, what gives? what the fuck happened?”
The Islamic Republic was never known to be the kindest, most people-friendly of governments. Ever. But growing up in that time in Iran, was such a radically different experience than those who had been born just a decade before me.
Ever since June 2009, I’ve gone back to those memories of growing up in Iran everyday, trying to decipher where the warning signals were (and boy there were plenty), what might have we done differently? I try to deconstruct those days, those experiences, not of nostalgia. But for the sake of understanding how we went from point A to point B, then to point C and beyond. Surely the narrative must go beyond the IRGC and Ahmadinejad. Even if this was a coup, the social and cultural norms in which it was embedded may provide a different, completing narrative.
I grew up with stories of the 80s executions, of war and revolution. Every so often, looking through the old family albums as I love to do, asking my grandmother: “mamanny, een kiyeh?” [grandma, whose this?] and then asking the person’s current age, location and occupation she would say: “khoda rahmatesh koneh. 67 edam shod” (god bless his/her soul. S/he was executed in 87).
Executions? WTF are those?
I remember the chill that went down my spine every time she said that, trying to imagine this smiley, jovial face in front of me in the album under the guillotine or in front of a fire squad.
“What? Why? What did he do?”
It took years of looking through those albums and asking those questions for “execution” to really fit in to the grander scheme of my life.
Such horror stories, though speaking of terror and agony, were so removed from my everyday experiences of growing up in Iran.
I grew up with stories of my aunts and uncles telling me of the harassment they and their friends had endured walking to school, at school, in front of their homes; of being stopped and searched in the streets; of going to police stations, of having their friends kicked out of school for the most outrageous reasons.
Just like the executions, those were terrible stories I heard, and yet they too were stories. I had no physical attachment to them, no physical, tangible experience to cling to.
By the time I was old enough to start collecting memories of the IRI, some of that notorious fear of my elders had subsided. The revolutionary fervor had died. The Bahais were still being persecuted, political prisoners were held galore, journalists were imprisoned. But we had numerous Bahai friends who still chose to stay in Iran, work in Iran, study there. Those journalists would eventually be freed and would pick up right where they left off. Political activism was not a dying breed, even despite the agony of political prisoners. We weren’t blind or oblivious to this suffering, but there was something in that vast, open land, that made things go on and made people stay. Because despite everything, we saw something there that maybe wasn’t visible to those who had focused their binoculars on our country, scanning it from afar.
From afar, the clergy has always been the clergy, the Guardian Council the notorious Guardian Council and intolerance and bigotry the same as they have always been.
But I swear, something was different. Many things were. It is attempting to understand and decipher these very differences and nuances, that I think might give us a better picture of what we see unravel today in Iran.
Some of the sweetest memories of my life are my high school days, growing up in Tehran with occasional and consistent visits to the south. Not of parties or street outings with friends, but of our actual school. I attended a strict religious [public] school where we had to wear chador (full black veil) to enter the school grounds. Having just arrived to Iran, off the boat, my parents never thought I would want or be willing to go. But after having spent a few months at a private school for recently returned expats, where the school was like a fashion show of (what I thought) were snobs and highbrow kids too stuck up for their own good, I was more than happy to wear that veil a few minutes a day.
In fact, once the initial culture shock had subsided, I was a happy kid, happy to be in that environment. Though in my school all the way around the world in North America I had occasionally met the philosopher king, or a kindred spirit, I didn’t like the way my compatriots in the West seemed (to me) so aloof, so pacified, so indifferent. It was invigorating to meet kids who were up to date with current events, who read voraciously, who could keep up a fiery political, social or religious debate better than most adults I knew.
In my childish, naive mind, it was as if putting up with injustice was the price we had to pay for having consciousness of injustice in the world. The moment things got too comfortable, things got dangerous. I thought that living through pain and intolerance, created an awareness and sensitivity to the world in a way that living in a pampered environment never would . It was as we call it, tofighe ejbari [a forced blessing].
Never did I imagine that for a while at least, my generation was the most pampered of all.
All of that debate and intellectual tête-à-tête would exponentially skyrocket near every election: the parliamentary elections, the city councils, the presidency. Yes, we have had the experience of vibrant elections. I have experienced elections in very different parts of the world, and if an election is about arousing and encouraging public debate, civil participation, a mindful struggle with opposing worldviews … we had vibrant elections. High school kids in Iran did not wake up to the Green Movement post June 2009. We had quite vivid, lively and yes, democratic participation throughout my high school days.
It didn’t matter who the candidates were or the limited pool (though not as limited as some claim) they came from. We would project our own worldviews, wants and principles on their candidacy, and take it from there. The state, knowing that such images would only boost its popular image at home and abroad, occasionally encouraged and emphasized this participation.
Some of the bravest, most brilliant activists, strategists and writers who became household names post-2009 were a product of that very era. So there must have been something there beyond the Guardian Council and Monsieur Jannati, although we would like to reduce it as such.
I remember the school the day the news of Dariush and Parvaneh Foruhar’s murder came out. The chain murders came as a great shock, they shook us like nothing did. But that’s the irony of it: executions, political murders, etc, these were nothing new in the practices of the IRI … so the fact that they shook us like they did, only showed how removed such events were from our daily lives.
I try to deconstruct those days,
“you were part of the lucky minority” – I was certainly lucky, I came from the religious, ethnic and political majority, but not a minority.
“you were bala shahri too out of touch with the common Iranian” [rich uptown folks] – certainly far from it.
etc, etc.
I don’t mean to blame 16 year olds for Iran’s current mess, but I do think we took it all for granted. We had all heard the horror stories of our elders, we all felt that something had progressed, … and we assumed it was a linear trajectory that we would simply continue. Yes, we still had a rather annoying, difficult old man we called the “supreme leader” (like the old, disgruntled father you are too embarrassed to have pick you up in front of school). Sure, we would have rather not had him in our family, but he was just the lame old man in the background. And if shit ever hit the fan one day, he would serve as a unifying force. He was velayat-e faqih [signaling wisdom] after all … those were the days before he was to cement his legacy as valayateh vaqih [vulgarity].
We were aware of the suffering of the Kurds, the Bahais, the Baluch. But their pain wasn’t on top of our agenda, we assumed it would all be “fixed”, this progress would only continue and magically uplift their anguish.
Yes, the more I think about it, the more I think that maybe because the horror stories were just that … stories … we didn’t fully realize all the violence and agony that had been endured to get us to that more comfortable state. Our life was our life, it had probably always been like this?
Well, it hadn’t always been like this. And it will never be again – for years to come. It was a small window through which we had the privilege of looking out onto the world. But to us, it wasn’t a small window, it didn’t smell of privilege, it was life as we had always known it to be.
Boy were we in for a surprise.

What a thing to have as a shared memory, parents and grandparents who recount stories from far gone days, and if you ask them whatever happened to that friend half of the stories end with “they got killed in year xx”. Growing up in different continents this is what we share then…
At any rate, thanks for another installment. By the way, have you read this article in Tehran Review, is it at all relevant for the people you see around you? http://tehranreview.net/articles/7691
All the best,
Sahand
Salaam Sahand,
Thanks for your note. It’s always an overstatement to claim things beyond your own self, and for an entire generation espcially. So I’m always curios to know of your experiences.
I agree with a lot of the assertions in that article. It’s been quite a roller coaster ride, just looking at the changes in my own perceptions of Iran. A strong anti-revolutionary and “pro” reform, I would argue too that the project of “reform” that Khatami set out to define is dead – for now. But that’s where I stop. Not sure where things can go from here. I think the author is making too many assumptions, especially on Iran’s revolutionary spirit, which I don’t believe exists in that capacity (I agree with Behnoud that fragmentation, and not totalitarianism by a minority is the biggest threat in Iran right now). I also think he’s glossing over the American revolution and its ability to “continually reform itself” – but that may also stem from my beef with the americans
Just a thought, perhaps not very appropriate to this situation, but when you are saying – more or less – that you got used to the horror and certain restrictions, I thought it may be like a Stockholm syndrome. You not only get used to the prison, you find excuses for the people keeping you there…
It’s not only under dictatorial regimes, also in democracies that people are just thinking all these horror stories… are just stories. And who cares ? We have our daily problems to solve, don’t we ?
Hi Gorbeh. I don’t agree with your assessment for several reasons. Most importantly, because we were aware of the calamities, we weren’t enamored with our policy makers, but we were also quite aware that things were progressing along for the better – we thought so at least. It was more a case of “Rome wasn’t built in a day” than being forcefully or blindly enthralled with our political leaders.
Maybe I wasn’t clear, but it wasn’t that we thought those stories were just random tales, but that we had no tangible, first hand life experience with them.
Oh now I wanna give you a hug and say: don’t worry kiddo we are all part of a grand scheme of learning. No fault on anyone. But we now have learned the biggest lesson of all: sweeping shit under the rug will hit the fan too.
As expats, I think we should also keep an eye on the surrounding politics that form our present. I think a changing Iran or Egypt or Iraq without a change in the imperialist Need and Greed of the industrial democracies is not going to be sustainable. We have the privilege of fighting two fronts; our idealism is thus global. So, rock on.
another tofique ejbari
Thanks Naj! virtual hug right back atchya! :*
Well that was just a thought, but it came from the paragraph where you say “it was as if putting up with injustice was the price we had to pay for having consciousness of injustice in the world”.
Being aware of calamaties is probably not preventing anyone from arranging with the situation (you know, I cannot judge and I really wonder how I would react in a similar case… and it’s frightening: I really do not know that, at all).
Didn’t mean to offend you.
Thanks for all that insight !
gorbeh, you didn’t offend me! Man kheyli poost koloftar az een harfam, I have very thick skin
That was trying to describe how I compared my North American classmates with Iranians. The North American ones mostly seemed (to me) pretty indifferent about the world. So very unlike my Iranian classmates. The difference was astounding, and I was trying to figure out why. In that time, the answer I came up with (as a 13/14 year old
) was that when living under too much comfort, people were bound to become indifferent and oblivious. But living in harsher conditions was what made us aware of the harshness in the world, a harshness that exists regardless of whether were aware of it or not. Which I thought my north american friends should have some sort of knowledge of, and they didn’t. I’m not sure why that’s stockholm’s syndrom
I had a very different experience in my school in North America, which was certainly the exception around here. In our school, we always talked policy and politics. We read Hannah Arendt, discussed Orientalism, Palestine/Israel, the Iraq War, and so on. My school was near Washington D.C., and our freshman class started a week before September 11. One girl’s father was killed in the attacks, and my Uncle’s office was hit by the Pentagon plane (though he wasn’t in it that day due to renovations, thank God!). My mother felt the earth shake when the plane hit the Pentagon, literally.
Soon after, a “sniper” started shooting people in parking lots and gas stations, and a random psycho sent Anthrax through the mail systems to local congressional offices. We weren’t allowed to go outside all year due to the sniper, and we were assigned a policeman to guard the school due to the number of kids attending with parents in the government.
It is by no means similar to growing up in Iran, but it brought the physical immediacy of our politics and world situation home in the starkest terms.
Thanks for sharing your experience in school!
Shayan
Once again, Pedestrian, such a great, thought-provoking post. I am now old enough to know that “progress” is not some linear trend as easy to predict as Moore’s law (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore's_law). It seems that we all need to continually engage with and in the process of democratization and reform without ever once giving in to the temporary comfort of our times, whatever they may be. It’s so much easier to think that problems, such as minority rights, will be solved, naturally with time. Especially after people embark on paths toward reform. I love your blog. You always make me think.
Tori, thanks for your note! Yes, it’s easy to think of progress in linear terms, especially if you are living in the midst of it. But perhaps the trajectory has some linear moments, thus giving the illusion that it will go on so forever. I’m grateful that I had a semi-taste for what “safety” is … it was one of those lucky moments I guess.